To secure Microsoft 365 for a small business, turn on multifactor authentication for everyone, block legacy sign-in, limit global administrators, stop automatic email forwarding, restrict external sharing and back up your data. Microsoft’s security defaults switch on several of these in one step. This guide lists the 12 settings to check and where to find them.
Key takeaways
- Security defaults turn on MFA and block legacy authentication for free.
- Keep only two or three global administrators, each with phishing-resistant MFA.
- Block automatic forwarding to external addresses to stop silent data theft.
- Microsoft 365 is not a backup: deleted or encrypted data may need a separate backup.
Why do you need to secure Microsoft 365?
Microsoft 365 holds your email, files and identities, so a single compromised account can expose the whole business. Microsoft secures the platform, but customers are responsible for how accounts, sharing and data protection are configured.
Email account takeover is the starting point for business email compromise, which cost US victims about $2.9 billion in a single year according to the FBI.
Which settings secure Microsoft 365 the most?
The settings that secure Microsoft 365 the most are MFA for all users, blocking legacy authentication, limiting admin accounts and stopping external email forwarding. Start with those four, then work through the rest of the checklist.
| # | Setting | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Security defaults or Conditional Access MFA | Stops password-only logins |
| 2 | Block legacy authentication | Old protocols bypass MFA |
| 3 | Two or three global admins only | Fewer powerful accounts to steal |
| 4 | Phishing-resistant MFA for admins | Admins are the main target |
| 5 | Block external auto-forwarding | Prevents silent mail theft |
| 6 | Alerts for new inbox rules | Detects BEC preparation |
| 7 | Restrict external sharing in SharePoint and OneDrive | Limits accidental data leaks |
| 8 | Enable audit logging | Lets you investigate incidents |
| 9 | SPF, DKIM and DMARC | Stops spoofing of your domain |
| 10 | Device compliance for access | Keeps unmanaged devices out |
| 11 | Third-party app consent restrictions | Stops malicious app permissions |
| 12 | Separate backup of mail and files | Recovers from deletion or ransomware |
How do you turn on Microsoft 365 security defaults?
You turn on security defaults in the Microsoft Entra admin center under Identity, Overview, Properties, Manage security defaults. Security defaults require MFA registration for all users, require MFA for administrators and block legacy authentication protocols.
Microsoft documents what they include in its security defaults guide. Larger businesses with Entra ID P1 or higher often use Conditional Access policies instead, which allow more control.
What baseline should a small business follow?
A small business can follow CISA’s Secure Cloud Business Applications (SCuBA) baselines, free security configuration guides for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace. They list recommended settings for Entra ID, Exchange Online, Defender, SharePoint and Teams.
See CISA SCuBA and our cloud security guides for related tools. Email domain protection is covered in DMARC, SPF and DKIM explained.
Do you need a separate backup for Microsoft 365?
Most businesses need a separate backup for Microsoft 365, because retention settings and the recycle bin are not designed for long-term recovery from ransomware, mass deletion or a compromised admin account. A third-party backup keeps independent copies.
Compare options in our guide to the best SaaS backup software for small businesses.
Related reading
Two-Factor Authentication Methods Compared: SMS, Apps, Keys and Passkeys
Best Free Cybersecurity Tools for Small Businesses
Best Email Security for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace
Frequently asked questions
Are Microsoft 365 security defaults free?
Yes. Security defaults are available at no extra cost in all Microsoft 365 tenants. They are a good starting point for businesses without Conditional Access licences.
What is legacy authentication and why block it?
Legacy authentication covers older email protocols such as POP and IMAP with basic authentication. They cannot enforce MFA, so attackers use them to try stolen passwords. Blocking them closes that gap.
How many global admins should we have?
Microsoft recommends fewer than five, and small businesses usually need two or three. Use separate admin accounts that are not used for daily email.
Can Microsoft 365 be hacked even with MFA?
Yes, through phishing kits that relay codes, session cookie theft or malicious app consent. Phishing-resistant MFA, short sessions and app consent controls reduce these risks.
Next steps
You can secure Microsoft 365 for a small business in an afternoon by working through these 12 settings, starting with MFA and legacy authentication. Write down what you changed so the next admin knows the baseline. Then check the rest of your security with the free Cybersecurity Readiness Assessment.





